Substitution


I don't know if someone else came up with a name for this concept but I'm going to call it Substitution:

I'm going to ask you a simple question and I want you to try to answer it as quickly as you can. Here it goes:

I pressed the ON/OFF button on my alarm clock 3 times and on the third press, the clock truned off. Does that mean that before I started, the clock was on or off?

Everyone I know will answer this question eventually. However I don't know anybody who can answer it in less than five seconds.

Substitution is a way of thinking that helps you answer such a question much quicker. When given a question, you throw it away, and replace it with a much easier question that has the same answer.

For example, recognizing that pressing the ON/OFF button twice has no effect whatsoever on the final state of the clock, you replace the above question with:

I pressed the ON/OFF button on my alarm clock once, and after that the clock turned off. Does that mean that before I started, the clock was on or off?

Much easier to answer, no? What you did here is took a question, and stripped it from all the elements and circumstances that are irrelevant to its answer. What you ended up with is a core question. One which describes a different scenario, not the same as the one at hand, but much simpler, and conveniently leads to the same answer.

I can think of many examples in my daily life where substitution comes in handy, and I'll be posting some later. In the meanwhile I want you to think of examples yourself, and post them back here.

Comments

Unknown said…
Very interesting concept! However your reasoning to deduce whether the alarm clock was on or off to start with stands on the premice that those are the only two functions possible - but what about snooze mode? That's your favorite though :-p

I'm trying to find a similar example of 'substitution' without success - please disclose yours!